How To Critique An Article Guide With Structure & Example
Begin each paragraph with a topic sentence, followed by supporting sentences. It would help if you had several arguments, where each argument falls under a separate paragraph. Also, check whether the author conducted in-depth research before writing the article. Also, at this stage, try and think of sources you will use to critique the research article at hand. Condense the content of the work by highlighting its main points and key supporting points. Some of the data you have selected do not seem as relevant to the overall aims of the paper. Although the most relevant data are selected, your picture of the authors’ aims and conclusions is not quite as clear and/or complete.
Each of these types of writing has specific language features and purposes. The authors provide a unique balance between psychoacoustic and electrophysiologic tests based on the type of lesion chosen. It must be noted that the various types of mental disorders have been taken into consideration to provide well-weighted research. The article meets its purpose of providing varied research based on the this contact form works of skilled experts in Psychiatry, Neurology, Neuropsychology, and Pediatric Psychology among other sciences. Although the educational factor is mentioned briefly as the article is more evidence-based, it leaves enough space for relevant scientific research. Remember that your article critique must cover not only the negative points that you encounter but the positive discoveries as well.
Ask whether the author’s logic make sense, for example, or if they demonstrate any bias in their writing. Look at any claims the author makes about other texts, then read those texts yourself to see if the author’s points are valid. A summary of a research article requires you to share the key points of the article so your reader can get a clear picture of what the article is about. One of the key things to look for when writing an article critique is the presence of any logical fallacies. Establishing that the author’s general idea follows logic is not easy, but it is an essential step to coping with the task. The article should have a conclusion that states one more time all the main points, while concurrently showing to readers the essence of essay critique to a specific field of specialization. Afterwards, you should add a reference list, in which all used sources are presented.
Types Of Critique
The papers are not supposed to be submitted for academic credit. Critique the adequacy of the study’s procedures and materials (e.g., interventions, interview protocols, data collection procedures). Evaluate the clarity and appropriateness of the research questions or hypotheses. How you construct your critique will be similar in all these cases, although you should always consider your intended audience. We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads.
Soheila Battaglia is a published and award-winning author and filmmaker. She holds an MA in literary cultures from New Get More Info York University and a BA in ethnic studies from UC Berkeley. She is a college professor of literature and composition.
- Deadlines and sleep-deprivation have become your constant companions.
- Review only when you are well-informed in that field.
- It is important to recognize the difference between summarizing an article and critiquing it.
The best way to get a grip on something is to see it closely and then try in person. So it is quite logical that students seek every available example of article critique to read closely and then use as a guideline for writing their own critique. When it goes how to learn here write an article critique, several components are a must while others may be skipped or replaced with something different. Introduce the subject of the critique and identify the author. Give some preliminary information indicating the main point to be discussed.
Formatting Your Article Critique
Compare the main argument of the author with other literature in the same field. As you critique an article, check for opinions that are likely to be influenced by issues such as politics, gender, race, economic status, and ethnicity. Another obvious indicator of bias is failing to include evidence that contradicts their arguments. talks about it Then, compare the main argument of the author with other literature in the same field. Now, it is time to check if your opinion holds water by gathering evidence. After reading the article 2 to 4 times, you should have a preliminary critique. Before you start gathering evidence, make sure you have a rough opinion of the article.
Yet, it does not have to turn into a listing of the contents! Knowing how to summarize and critique an article means helping your audience see all the key points of the article along with the author’s ideas, objectives, or major intentions. The main purpose of every article critique is to reveal the strengths and the weaknesses of the article by keeping the tone neutral in terms of personal considerations. If you want to learn click this site, you should first have a clear understanding of what this assignment is about. You need to give the reader an idea of whether the author of an article based it on facts and credible information.
You must focus on the article’s content and do your very best to understand it–how and why the author wrote it, its strengths and weaknesses, purpose and effects. Remember that an article critique is just one kind of essay, and there are many others that have different requirements. It is not a secret that most of professors pay careful attention not only to the content of the assignment but also how well it is formatted. That is why you need to be very attentive, when shaping your work and adding final changes. One of the most popular formatting styles, while completing an article critique is American Psychological Association format, which has its specific rules and guidelines.
Thus, they may ignore contrary evidence or even misinterpret it, so they will turn it to their advantage. If the author’s style is incomprehensive, you may use that argument as an element of your critique. In addition to identifying the main idea of the article, you should also clarify its background and purpose. State your informed opinions about the clarity, relevancy, and accuracy of the article, using specific examples from the article to support your statements. Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the article that you noted while critically reading the article. Read the article to get an understanding of the main idea. Ontario, a province in Canada, understands this and has come up with an initiative and policies to improve equity in their schools.